The Gremlins of Governance, July/August 2009

Trusteeship Magazine Cover image
July/August
2009
Volume: 
17
Number: 
4

This issue of Trusteeship provides a picture of the current environment for campus governance, as well as some guidance. William Freund, chief economist emeritus of the New York Stock Exchange, offers his reflections on the economy and the "slow, gradual, and tedious" recovery before us. State legislators Geanie Morrison and Denise Merrill suggest that now is the time for state legislatures to engage more directly with higher education to accomplish state goals. The challenge, they argue, is finding new ways to address the educational needs of states and citizens, even in this new turbulent economy.

Tom Hyatt offers guidance on the new IRS Form 990, the implementation of which is affecting boards of all independent institutions, as well as the foundations of public colleges and universities. Part of the new focus on board and institutional accountability, this "new report card" is sure to have more public audiences than the previous form, but it also offers a way to verify "use of best practices in governing policies and procedures."

Governance guru Dick Chait does what he does best--he questions "common knowledge" about governance. Instead of focusing so much on policies and procedures, he would have boards pay attention to their culture to avoid being "lawfully mediocre."

"Interesting Times" for Governing Boards

"May you live in interesting times." While the source of thisexpression is unknown, its meaning is clear. The more "interesting" the times, the more challenging you will find them. Certainly this academic year proved to be among the most "interesting" in memory, and one suspects that next year will be more of the same.

The Gremlins of Governance

Richard Chait

A Trusteeship Q&A with Richard Chait, research professor at the Harvard Graduate School of Education. He kicked off the recent AGB National Conference on Trusteeship with a plenary speech about the "Gremlins of Governance," three major challenges that face college and university governing boards today--in the areas of board structure, planning, and trustee selection.

Show Me What I'm Looking For: A Trustee's Guide to Reviewing the New IRS Form 990

Much has been made of the Internal Revenue Service's introduction of the completely revised Form 990 last year. The new Form 990 is no longer a document focused on financial data. It is now a governance-centric document that places its primary focus on the work of the governing body. The board must now be a partner with management and the organization's consultants to ensure that the organization's governance is effective, up-to-date, and properly explained to the public.

Your Institution in a Global Economy

William Freund

Clearly, what we are experiencing now is not one of the ordinary recessions that we have experienced since World War II. What we've seen is a bursting of a bubble in the credit markets and in financial institutions--with the effects spreading globally.

Getting By Isn't Good Enough for Higher Education

Geanie Morrison and Denise Merrill

The economic meltdown has hit our college campuses, and higher education is on the chopping block in state budgets, with cuts totaling hundreds of millions of dollars already approved and hundreds of millions in more cuts on the way. As veteran legislators, we have seen this story play out before in previous recessions.

Presidential Transition Teams: Fostering a Collaborative Transition Process

Richard B. Artman and Mark Franz

So you've hired a new president, now what? Whether hiring a sitting president or one beginning a first presidency, the board of trustees should be keenly interested in ensuring that the new president's first months in office flow as smoothly as possible. Increasing attention has been paid in recent years to the idea of using a transition team to assist the new president, and our experience--as a newly hired president and as the leader of his presidential transition team--leads us to strongly endorse this approach.

Perspective on the News

A sampling of national media coverage of higher education in the last two months.

Developing Rules of Engagement for Boards

A board must establish a set of operational rules of engagement if it is going to appropriately fulfill its obligations.

Is Your Institution a Sitting Duck for Campus Whistleblowers?

Pamela J. Bernard

Acting to head off claims and shoring up internal systems can save an institution millions in financial penalties and legal fees.

Three-Year Degrees? Changing Times May Demand Them

Edwin H. Welch

The four-year degree has been the staple of American higher education since the founding of Harvard University in 1636.

Faculty Pay for Performance?

Adele Phelan

How to evaluate faculty members in a way that they see as fair has long plagued education in general and higher education in particular.

Data on Board Orientation Practices Highlighted in New AGB Surveys

Merrill Schwartz

The recently published AGB Survey on Higher Education Governance, supported by the TIAACREF Institute, examined practices ranging from trustee assessment to presidential compensation. Part of the survey dealt with practices regarding board orientations.

Following are highlights of the findings on orientations. 

What are the College Prospects for Young Non-Citizens?

Helen Aguirre Ferré

A recent portrait of undocumented immigrants by the Pew Hispanic Center reveals that most children of undocumented residents living in the U.S. are actually citizens. According to "A Portrait of Unauthorized Immigrants in the United States," 73 percent of children in undocumented or mixed-status families (with a parent or sibling undocumented) were born in the U.S. That adds up to approximately four million young people, contrasted with a million and a half undocumented youths.