Skip to main content

The bimonthly magazine published by the Association of Governing Boards of Universities and Colleges

FEATURE

Volume 34,  Number 6   //    November/December 2026

When Trustees Take Charge: Breaking Governance Rules and Mending Them Again

By Terrence MacTaggart

Ordinarily, the board of trustees is expected to provide oversight as fiduciaries, but sometimes, there are extenuating circumstances in which they must become more involved with the institution’s operations. If some overstepping is warranted, in very challenging and specific situations, it is important that trustees resume their oversight role and step back once again after the storm passes.

Imagine that you are a board chair of a higher education institution and this scenario occurs:

The Chair’s Dilemma

The college is in chaos. The president so recently hired has resigned in the face of a second arrest for driving while intoxicated. There is no obvious replacement among the cabinet members and deans. The board summons a respected music professor out of retirement as a stop gap. Fall enrollments continue to decline, only now more sharply as the media feed on the scandal. Rumors of a faculty no-confidence vote in the board abound. Meanwhile, the regional accrediting authority launches an investigation. Big-dollar donors urge suspending their fundraising campaign until order can be restored.

Trustees pepper the newly elected chair with contradictory advice. Several argue that the time has come for “muscular” trustee leadership, but what exactly that means is unclear. Others advise her to stay above the fray even as the college’s reputation disintegrates. They insist that only a new president can lead a turnaround, though there is no agreement on who that would be. Even a placeholder, they argue, is better than a trustee stepping in as the president. Her closest friends on the board encourage her to consider becoming the president herself for at least for a year or two.


Login or become a member to access this AGB member-exclusive resource.

Terrence MacTaggart

Close Menu
The owner of this website has made a commitment to accessibility and inclusion, please report any problems that you encounter using the contact form on this website. This site uses the WP ADA Compliance Check plugin to enhance accessibility.