Listen to this article on the AGB Soundboard App
Photo courtesy of Phillip Levine
An interview with Phillip Levine
Phillip Levine, PhD, is the Katharine Coman and A. Barton Hepburn professor of economics at Wellesley College and senior fellow for Higher Ed Affordability and Transparency Initiatives at the College Board. He created MyinTuition, now operated by the College Board, and recently published Hidden Tuition: An Insider’s Guide to College Pricing and Financial Aid.
What are the main shortcomings of our current tuition-pricing system?
The biggest shortcoming of our current tuition-pricing system is the disconnect between the price colleges post and the price many students actually pay. Many students and families know only the full sticker price of college, which is often a very large number. That is the easiest number to find because colleges are required to publish it. But most students pay less than that, and they often don’t know what their actual price will be. As a result, students and families commonly overestimate what college will cost them.
This matters because students make educational decisions based on the prices they perceive, and those perceptions are not always accurate. Ideally, students should attend institutions that are a good fit for them in a broad sense—based on their academic abilities, fields of interest, preferences for a particular type of educational or social environment, and many other factors. College isn’t the right choice for everyone. But for those who want a college degree, inaccurate perceptions of price should not prevent them from considering options that might otherwise be a good fit.
This is not to say that college affordability isn’t a legitimate problem. It is and addressing it requires a separate discussion about the underlying finances of higher education. But if some students are making decisions based on prices they mistakenly believe they will have to pay, that is a different problem—and one that should be much easier to address.
How can higher education better make the case for affordability despite high sticker prices?
If most students pay less than the sticker price, and they don’t know that, then colleges need an easy, low-friction way to share and promote actual costs. That doesn’t mean using complex language about financial need or emphasizing the general availability of scholarships and loans. It means providing students with a number: For you, how much is our college likely to cost?
Unfortunately, that isn’t easy to do. The financial aid system is complicated. Students and their parents provide extensive information about income, assets, and other circumstances, which colleges use to determine need-based aid. There is also merit aid, which can reduce the cost particularly for students who don’t qualify for need-based aid. Combining all of this to produce an exact net price early in the college planning process can be difficult. The federal government requires colleges to post net price calculators, but they are often complicated as well.
But early in the process, students don’t need an exact estimate. A ballpark estimate, coupled with a range within which the actual price is likely to fall, can suffice. Limited financial information about a family’s finances based on easily known values can generate such an estimate. That’s what colleges can use to easily tell a family whether the cost is within reach—not exhaustive detail, just enough to keep them in the conversation.
Why is it so difficult for colleges to simply lower their prices?
The public’s perception of rising college prices was accurate in earlier decades, for both sticker prices and net prices, but not recently. Net prices have fallen over the past decade, and sticker prices are about the same today as a decade ago, after adjusting for inflation. These facts are inconsistent with public perceptions.
That said, it is difficult for colleges to lower prices. Colleges have substantial operating costs and, for those that are nonprofit, the revenue they receive has to cover those costs. Students who pay close to the sticker price may cover a larger share of those costs, but students receiving substantial financial aid do not. The difference has to be filled in elsewhere, perhaps from the government or investment returns generated from an endowment. But the government tends to provide insufficient funding and only a handful of colleges have endowments large enough to fill that gap. Lowering prices make it harder to balance the books.
Reducing costs isn’t a simple solution either. Students demand educational opportunities and services, as well as facilities and amenities. Cutting those offerings can reduce costs, but it can also make a college less attractive to prospective students.
So, while colleges have found ways to lower prices recently, doing so is not as simple as cutting tuition. Colleges must balance the prices different students pay against the costs of providing the education and services they expect. The recent decline in net prices reflects the effort many colleges have made to do just that.
–Interview by Justine Ballard, Trusteeship assistant editor


