Skip to main content

Why Transformation Often Waits for Presidential Transition—And Why It Shouldn’t

By Justin Kollinger November 16, 2026 Blog Post

Opinions expressed in AGB blogs are those of the authors and not necessarily those of the institutions that employ them or of AGB.

Over hundreds of conversations AGB Consulting has had with governing boards and presidents across the country in the last year, a pattern has become impossible to ignore: The most consequential strategic work happens when change in the president’s office is, or might be, imminent. During these times, trustees ask harder questions than usual.

This is not a coincidence. It reflects a structural feature of the president-board relationship that boards should understand well before a transition forces the issue.

The Incentive Gap

A sitting president has every reason to tell the board a reassuring story: “I understand the challenges. I have a plan. You don’t need to worry about this.” That instinct is often sincere, and frequently accurate. But it also can keep the board’s attention at too much of a distance from how the institution is functioning.

Governing boards need to maintain objective strategic oversight without overstepping into management. The board’s job is to see the situation on the ground clearly, not just to be reassured. Fiduciary duty requires the board to independently understand revenue trends, market position, and the sustainability of the cost structure, regardless of how confident the president’s narrative sounds.

In a stable presidency, those two incentives (strategic oversight and understanding the facts on the ground) are often in quiet tension. The president manages the story; the board, trusting the relationship, generally accepts it. Neither party is acting in bad faith, but if trustees are not asking perceptive questions, it can lead a board to be less informed than it realizes.

What Changes During Transition

When a transition is coming—a planned retirement, an interim president named, or even a scheduled presidential assessment—the dynamic shifts. The board leans into its role to monitor institutional health and make its own decisions, rather than simply relying on the administration’s regular reports.

Three recent examples illustrate how this plays out.

  • A 16-year president gave the board notice about a year and half before retirement. The board’s first instinct was reasonable: Define the profile of the next president. However, as board leadership dug into the university’s enrollment, philanthropy, and cost structure to inform the profile, they discovered they needed far more than a good hire. They needed a genuine strategic reset, and quickly.
  • An incoming interim president found that the financial runway was shorter than prior leadership had assumed and informed the board chair. That discovery shifted the focus of their interim presidency. The question was no longer how to manage steady-state operations, but how to sustain the mission on a compressed timeline, whether through enrollment growth and repositioning or through a partnership or a merger.
  • A college following good governance practices led to a shift in the incentive structure. That board committed to a 360 presidential assessment (a review that gathers confidential input from a significant cross-section of the campus community and external stakeholders) every three years, creating a safe opening for the board to ask whether the sitting president had the capability to lead the strategic change the moment required. Without an actual vacancy to force the question, the board still found itself taking a more active role in defining the path forward, leading to creation of a new cabinet-level position to lead one of the key strategic initiatives where the president needed support to be successful.

The Depth Isn’t Visible from the Outset

From working with AGB members, we’ve seen that board leaders rarely know, at the start, how deep the inquiry needs to go when they are seeking a new president or evaluating a sitting president. What looks at first like a search profile, a financial check-in, or a routine assessment ultimately reveals itself as a larger need only through sustained, structured inquiry. Boards that keep pulling the thread find out what they actually need to know.

For example, the college defining its next president’s profile didn’t begin by asking about cost structure. That question emerged after the initial inquiry created more questions than it answered. The interim president didn’t start with “should we pursue a merger?” That question surfaced only once the true financial runway came into view.

The Lesson Is About Structure and Oversight, Not Transition

It would be easy to conclude that boards do their best work during transitions, but that undersells the real lesson: boards can do this level of work at any time. A presidential transition removes the social and structural friction that normally discourages boards’ deeper inquiry.

Boards that wait for transition to look closely at institutional functioning are allowing a structural incentive—not a governance decision—to determine when they do their most important work. The institutions best positioned for what comes next are the ones whose boards ask transition-level questions routinely, not only when circumstances finally force the issue.

Getting to that clear-eyed view is rarely a solo effort for a board. It takes expert insight from someone who has seen and heard it all before. If you’re a board chair, vice chair, or president who suspects there’s more beneath the surface than your institution has yet uncovered, that’s a conversation worth having now, not after the next transition forces it.

Justin Kollinger is associate vice president of AGB Consulting and a co-author of Risk Management: An Accountability Guide for University and College Boards, Second Edition. Contact him at jkollinger@agb.org or AGB’s membership team at Membership@agb.org to discuss how AGB can support you.

Artificial intelligence tools, including AGB Board BotTM, assisted in the development of this blog post.

Close Menu
The owner of this website has made a commitment to accessibility and inclusion, please report any problems that you encounter using the contact form on this website. This site uses the WP ADA Compliance Check plugin to enhance accessibility.